Cambridge Civic Journal Forum

November 25, 2025

Short and Curious – November 24, 2025 Cambridge City Council meeting

Short and Curious – November 24, 2025 Cambridge City Council meeting

Though the agenda is short and uneventful, I suspect the personnel shakeup reported in the Harvard Crimson is liable to generate some conversation as it relates to On The Table #2. Here goes:City Hall

Manager’s Agenda #1. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to Awaiting Report Item Number 25-60, which requested a comprehensive report on Gold Star Mothers Memorial Park. [text of report]
pulled by Zusy; comments by Zusy, Sobrinho-Wheeler, DPW Commissioner John Nardone, Nolan; [Kevin Beutel, Health Commissioner Sam Lipson also in attendance]; Placed on File 9-0

Manager’s Agenda #2. Transmitting Communication from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to the appropriation of $1,000,000, from Free Cash to the Public Investment Fund Public Works Department Extraordinary Expenditures account. These funds will support the removal of stockpiled contaminated soil and initiate the design phase for the remediation and reconstruction of Gold Star Mothers Park. [text of report]
pulled by Zusy; comments by Zusy, John Nardone, Deputy City Manager Kathy Watkins, City Manager Yi-An Huang; Order Adopted 9-0

Manager’s Agenda #3. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to Awaiting Report Item Number 25-56, regarding an update on rodent control citywide. [text of report]
pulled by Nolan; comments by Nolan, John Nardone, Rat Czar Dave Powers (Inspectional Services), Sam Lipson, Wilson, Yi-An Huang, Simmons; Anthony Tuccinardi (Inspectional Services), Toner (on coyotes); Placed on File 9-0


On The Table #2. That the City Manager is requested to explore with the Government Operations Committee whether the functions of the Peace Commission may be improved and enhanced by bringing them within another City Commission or Department, such as the Human Rights Commission, and report back in a timely manner. [Charter Right – Simmons, May 19, 2025; Tabled June 2, 2025] (PO25#76)

Late Order #2. Update on Organizational Changes to the Equity & Inclusion Department.   Councillor Nolan, Councillor Siddiqui, Councillor Sobrinho-Wheeler, Councillor Wilson, Vice Mayor McGovern
taken up early; comments by Wilson, Nolan, Azeem, Raecia Catchings (“Chief People Officer”), Sobrinho-Wheeler (who expresses desire that City Council should have control over City personnel matters), Siddiqui, Toner, Simmons, City Solicitor Megan Bayer (raises issue of whether any of this qualifies for possible Executive Session), McGovern; remarks by City Manager Yi-An Huang on how this action came about, accountability, investments in “equity and inclusion” – defers responses to subordinates; Deidre Travis Brown (Chief of Equity and Inclusion) on duplication of effort among commissions, efficiency and effectiveness; Rae Catchings (on the “runway needed” for future actions); Zusy, Siddiqui, McGovern (wants to be added as sponsor), Nolan, Wilson, Yi-An Huang (on future restructuring and staffing changes); amendment to add McGovern and one line adopted 8-0-1 (Azeem Absent); comments by Simmons, Zusy; Order Adopted as Amended 5-3-1 (Toner, Zusy, Simmons – No; Azeem – Absent)


Committee Report #1. The Health and Environment Committee held a public hearing on Wed, Oct 29, 2025 to review and discuss energy planning in Cambridge including expanding electricity capacity, expanding renewable energy productions, BEUDO energy requirements, and thermal energy network planning and any other topics relevant to the city’s overall planning for ensuring city goals of electrification may be met. [text of report]
Report Accepted, Placed on File 7-2-0 (Azeem, Siddiqui – Absent)

November 19, 2025

Cambridge InsideOut Episodes 655-656: November 18, 2025

Episode 655 – Cambridge InsideOut: Nov 18, 2025 (Part 1)

This episode was broadcast on Nov 18, 2025 at 6:00pm. Topics: 2025 Municipal Election – error, test ballots, controversy, preliminary, unofficial, official results; alphabetical bias in Ranked Choice Voting; Round-by-Round City Council results; School Committee, Teachers Union (CEA) slate and disinterested voters; Factions and Slates; Mamdani Effect. Host: Robert Winters [On YouTube] [audio]


Episode 656 – Cambridge InsideOut: Nov 18, 2025 (Part 2)

This episode was broadcast on Nov 18, 2025 at 6:30pm. Topics: 2025 Municipal Election – Round-by-Round School Committee results; ballot data, configuration files, ChoicePlusPro tabulation; new City Charter approved – Election Commission flexibility, School Committee to choose their own Chair; Replacements in the event of a vacancy; Instant Runoff Mayoral and School Committee Chair simulations; #1 votes distributions by ward/precinct; #2 votes distributions behind each candidates #1 votes; What might we expect in the new year? Host: Robert Winters [On YouTube] [audio]

[Materials used in these episodes]

November 16, 2025

2025 Cambridge Final Election Results (and some curiosities)

Official Results (Fri, Nov 14):
City Council
(in order of election):
Sumbul Siddiqui
Marc C. McGovern
Ayah Al-Zubi
Cathie Zusy
Burhan Azeem
Jivan G. Sobrinho-Wheeler
Tim Flaherty
E. Denise Simmons
Patricia M. Nolan
Official Results (Fri, Nov 14):
School Committee
(in order of election):
Elizabeth Hudson
Richard Harding
Luisa De Paula Santos
Caitlin Dube
Arjun Jaikumar
David Weinstein
Charter Ballot Question:
Yes:  18,414 (73%)
No:     5,899 (23%)
Blank: 1,039 (4%)
Total: 25,352 (100%)
Round-by-Round Results (HTML) – official City version Round-by-Round Results (HTML) – official City version  
Spreadsheet (PDF) – with transfer details Spreadsheet (PDF) – with transfer details  
City Council #1 Votes by Ward/Precinct School Committee #1 Votes by Ward/Precinct  
City Council #2 Vote Distribution School Committee #2 Vote Distribution  
Replacements (should a vacancy occur in the upcoming 2026-2027 term):
City Council:
Al-Zubi –> Rifkin
Azeem –> Bullister
Flaherty –> Hanratty
McGovern –> Bullister
Nolan –> Bullister
Siddiqui –> Wilson
Simmons –> Wilson
Sobrinho-Wheeler –> Bullister
Zusy –> Hanratty
School Committee:
De Paula Santos –> Havstad
Dube –> Goetz
Harding –> Hunter
Hudson –> Schraa Huh
Jaikumar –> Goetz
Weinstein –> Rojas Villarreal
What would happen if we used this year’s City Council and School Committee ballots in a Runoff to determine the Chair of each?
Instant Mayor:
Count 7: McGovern 8377, Siddiqui 8012; Zusy 5748
Count 8: McGovern 9330, Siddiqui 8786
Instant School Committee Chair:
Count 4: Hudson 6690, de Paula Santos 6674, Harding 5693
Count 5: Hudson 9526, dePaula Santos 7226

November 7, 2025

Unofficial Cambridge Election Results (Nov 7, 2025)

Filed under: 2025 election,Cambridge,Charter,City Council,elections,School Committee — Robert Winters @ 8:27 pm

School Committee Unofficial Election Reversal

Nov 7, 2025 – The Unofficial Election Results have now been determined. Due to an error in which the ballot data from a test deck of ballots was not cleared prior to the tabulation of the actual City Council and School Committee votes, the Preliminary Results (Nov 4) contained significant errors. In the newly tabulated Unofficial Election Results, David Weinstein is unofficially reelected to the School Committee and Eugenia Schraa Huh is not elected. The unofficial winners in the City Council race are the same – though the order of election has changed.

Unofficial Results (Fri, Nov 7):
City Council
(in order of election):
Sumbul Siddiqui
Marc C. McGovern
Ayah Al-Zubi
Cathie Zusy
Burhan Azeem
Jivan G. Sobrinho-Wheeler
Tim Flaherty
E. Denise Simmons
Patricia M. Nolan
Unofficial Results (Fri, Nov 7):
School Committee
(in order of election):
Elizabeth Hudson
Richard Harding
Luisa De Paula Santos
Caitlin Dube
Arjun Jaikumar
David Weinstein
Charter Ballot Question:
Yes:  18,406 (73%)
No:     5,899 (23%)
Blank: 1,046 (4%)
Round-by-Round Results (HTML) – official City version Round-by-Round Results (HTML) – official City version  
Spreadsheet (PDF) – with transfer details Spreadsheet (PDF) – with transfer details  
Note: The Final Official Election Results will be determined on Friday, November 14. – RW

Election Commission Statement Regarding Cambridge Municipal Election Preliminary Unofficial Results From November 4th
The Cambridge Election Commission conducts rigorous and mandatory prequalified testing for every election. Through its proactive auditing process, the Election Commission determined that ballots used for testing were not fully cleared from the Election Management System by the vendor in advance of the Municipal Election on November 4, 2025.

As a result, the preliminary unofficial results for the 2025 Municipal Election that were released early November 5 included both the ballots processed election night and the test ballots, which produced 2,158 additional records (632 for the City Council, 1,370 for the School Committee, and 156 for the Ballot Question).

The Election Commission has since removed all test ballots and retabulated the unofficial election results, which also now includes ballots counted Wednesday, November 5 through Friday, November 7.

With the updated Count-by-Count Unofficial results and the removal of the test ballots, there has been a change in the announced candidates from Friday’s School Committee unofficial results versus what was originally announced as part of the unofficial preliminary results late Tuesday night. There have been no changes to the named candidates in the City Council unofficial results or the yes vote in support of the ballot question.

Preliminary unofficial results are made available by the Election Commission to the community, media organizations, and other interested individuals as soon as they are available on Election Night. However, results are subject to change as additional ballots are counted and tallies are confirmed through a series of checks and balances. As a result of this thorough auditing process, a discrepancy associated with the test ballots was discovered.

November 5, 2025

Preliminary Cambridge Election Results (Nov 4, 2025)

Preliminary Results (Tues, Nov 4):
City Council
(in order of election):
Marc C. McGovern
Sumbul Siddiqui
Ayah Al-Zubi
Burhan Azeem
Jivan G. Sobrinho-Wheeler
E. Denise Simmons
Tim Flaherty
Cathie Zusy
Patricia M. Nolan
Preliminary Results (Tues, Nov 4):
School Committee
(in order of election):
Elizabeth Hudson
Richard Harding
Luisa De Paula Santos
Caitlin Dube
Arjun Jaikumar
Eugenia Schraa Huh
Charter Ballot Question:
Yes: 17,930 (75.5%)
No:    5,824 (24.5%)
Round-by-Round Results (PDF) – official City version Round-by-Round Results (PDF) – official City version  
Spreadsheet (PDF) – with transfer details Spreadsheet (PDF) – with transfer details  

October 31, 2025

The Proposed Cambridge City Charter

The Proposed Cambridge City Charter

Oct 31, 2025 – I have been meaning to write up my thoughts on the proposed new Charter, but so many things all at once have been getting in my way. Many people have been asking me about it, so here are some thoughts:Robert Winters

Basically, it will be OK whether or not it passes. Virtually all of the Plan E provisions will remain – albeit it with some language revision and a relatively small number of actual changes.

The bottom line for me was the following:

(a) allow the Election Commission the freedom to approve a tabulation method for the PR Count that is independent of the order in which the ballots are counted;

(b) maintain the city manager form of government;

(c) maintain the practice of the City Council electing its own Chair, i.e. The Mayor;

(d) allow the School Committee to choose its own Chair.

If I had my druthers (which I don’t and I don’t really even know what that word means), I would have:

(a) created a new elected advisory council with representation from all the city’s neighborhoods that could propose legislation to the City Council and require a vote.

(b) rescinded the authority of the City Council to approve board appointments (they actually increased it – bummer)

(c) enhance the citizen petition mechanism to require a City Council vote on the substance of a petition with sufficient signatures.

I was not thrilled with the efforts of some city councillors to gain more power over city management, e.g. the power to approve or deny appointment of City department heads – a surefire way to bring back political patronage. Thankfully we were able to beat back that proposal. I was also quite horrified that some councillors wanted to give themselves the power to reallocate essentially all of the discretionary budget of any City department to other City departments. Again, we were able to beat back that effort. There were other disastrously misguided recommendations from the Charter Review Committee that were thankfully voted down or delayed to another day (or never).

I felt that the entire Charter Review process was flawed from beginning to end. Just as one example, the initial City Council vote was to completely eliminate the citizen right to petition based on the belief that it is already guaranteed in state law. It isn’t. That right was only restored when I convinced a few councillors and the Law Department that the City Council was in error – and they rescinded their prior vote and restored the right to petition.

I plan to vote for the new Charter – not because it’s perfect or what I would ideally want, but because it met my minimum requirements (see above).

Robert

September 17, 2025

Cambridge InsideOut Episodes 653-654: September 16, 2025

Episode 653 – Cambridge InsideOut: Sept 16, 2025 (Part 1)

This episode was broadcast on Sept 16, 2025 at 6:00pm. Topics: Candidates, Candidate Pages, campaign finance facts and figures, PACs and slates; importance of non-hostility; voting histories; pros and cons of candidacy; School Committee candidate forums, Cambridge Education Association (CEA) hostility; general impressions of School Committee candidates; respectful Cambridge Advanced Learners Association (CALA) candidate forum. Host: Robert Winters [On YouTube] [audio]


Episode 654 – Cambridge InsideOut: Sept 16, 2025 (Part 2)

This episode was broadcast on Sept 16, 2025 at 6:30pm. Topics: Hunter ballot challenge, illegitimacy of The Black Response; adopted Cantabrigian; Public Safety meeting on Aug 2 incident, extraordinary offerts of CPD to protect everyone, activist idiocy and HEART, police as social workers; CPA funds, voters have no say in their own taxation; City Charter updates; dissing Broadway residents; Bow St. pedestrianization; Harvard tunnel concept and fiscal constraints; proposed Mass. Ave. upzoning to 12 stories from Cambridge Common to the Arlington line, potential ABC political fallout, Inclusionary connection; Office of Tourism and the business associations; Radical Centrist. Host: Robert Winters [On YouTube] [audio]

[Materials used in these episodes]

September 15, 2025

Revision Cambridge – September 15, 2025 Cambridge City Council meeting

Revision Cambridge – September 15, 2025 Cambridge City Council meeting

Here’s my first pass at the highlights. Revisions, comments, etc. to follow:

Manager’s Agenda #1. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to recommendations of the Community Preservation Act Committee (CPAC) for FY2026. [text of report]
pulled by Simmons; comments by Taha Jennings, Nolan, Zusy
VOTE 1: Fiscal Year 2026 Local Funds ($19,700,000) voted 9-0
VOTE 2: Fiscal Year 2025 State Matching Funds [received in FY2026] ($2,800,000) voted 9-0
VOTE 3: CPA Fund Balance – Administration ($15,000) voted 9-0
VOTE 4: Historic Preservation Reserve ($113,000) voted 9-0
VOTE 5: Open Space Reserve ($331,000) voted 9-0

80%-10%-10% from now until the end of time – non-debatable. Anything else might be interpreted as democratic.

Manager’s Agenda #2. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to Awaiting Report Item Number #25-50, regarding a Deadline for Charter Change.
pulled by Simmons; Megan Bayer notes that House and Senate approved, sent to Governor to sign, Election Commission preparing guides, ballot; Yi-An Huang thanks Sal DiDomenico, Marjorie Decker, now just waiting for Governor’s signature; Tanya Ford provided updates; comments by Simmons, Nolan, Megan Bayer (not the full text on the ballot or the guide – just the summary), Wilson, Siddiqui, Zusy, Simmons (special thank you to Tanya Ford); Placed on File 9-0

I’m presuming this means that it’s got the go-ahead. For those who are paying attention, the proposed Charter is fundamentally the same as the Plan E Charter that has worked well for the City of Cambridge since its adoption in 1940. Thankfully, all the problematic proposals were beaten back, but all that could soon change if a clown car is elected in November for the next City Council.

Manager’s Agenda #7. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to Awaiting Report Item Numbers 25-38, 25-39 and 25-41, regarding issues related to parking in the area surrounding the eastern end of Broadway. [text of report]
pulled by Zusy; comments by Zusy, Brooke McKenna (evasive re: parking for employees at 344 Broadway), Wilson (notes large number of School and City staff who park on Broadway), Siddiqui, Toner, Nolan, Stephanie Groh; Placed on File 9-0

Manager’s Agenda #8. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to Awaiting Report Item Number 25-27, regarding the City Manager investigate bike pod storage options to be placed in suitable areas in the city to provide residents and visitors safe storage options. [text of report]
pulled by Wilson; comments by Wilson, Stephanie Groh, Simmons; Placed on File 9-0

Manager’s Agenda #9. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to Awaiting Report Item Number 25-42 regarding pedestrianization of Lower Bow Street. [text of report]
pulled by Nolan; comments by Nolan (wants auto-bollards), Kathy Watkins; Placed on File 9-0


Manager’s Agenda #10. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to Awaiting Report Item Number 25-32, regarding a request that the City engage in discussions with leadership from the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) and the Harvard Square Business Association (HSBA) regarding a proposal to explore the feasibility of repurposing the long-abandoned MBTA tunnel in Harvard Square into a commercial or cultural space. [text of report]
pulled by Simmons; comments by Simmons (disappointed), Zusy, Azeem; Charter Right – Azeem

Order #1. That the City Manager is requested to provide an update to the City Council at the September 29, 2025 City Council meeting regarding the status of discussions with the MBTA and HSBA, the potential allocation of funds for the tunnel feasibility RFP, and any anticipated next steps in this process.   Mayor Simmons, Vice Mayor McGovern, Councillor Toner
pulled by Simmons; comments by Simmons, McGovern, Nolan; Order Adopted 9-0

Though I think this is a fabulous idea worth exploring, I would not recommend holding your breath waiting for movement on this. There are multiple parties involved – both public and private, and even one-ball juggling often proves far too difficult when undertaking creative ideas involving more than one party.


Manager’s Agenda #11. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to the transmission of the Cambridge Street Zoning Petition. [text of report]
pulled by McGovern; comments by McGovern; Zoning Petition referred to Ordinance Committee & Planning Board 8-1 (Zusy – No)Upping Mass Ave

Manager’s Agenda #12. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to the transmission of the Massachusetts Avenue Zoning Petition. [text of report]
pulled by McGovern; comments by McGovern; Zoning Petition referred to Ordinance Committee & Planning Board 8-1 (Zusy – No)

Manager’s Agenda #13. A communication transmitted from Yi-An Huang, City Manager, relative to Awaiting Report Item Number 25-43, regarding a request for an interim report on demolition and building permit applications received during the six-month period following the City Council’s adoption of the Multifamily Housing Zoning Amendment on February 10th, 2025. [text of report]
pulled by McGovern; comments by McGovern (17 demolition petitions filed, 7 issued since MFZ passed); Jeff Roberts (CDD) says 46 applications submitted and of these 13 issued to date, 13 for residential demolitions and 7 issued; McGovern desperately trying to put a positive spin on this; Nolan; Melissa Peters (CDD); Jacob Lazzara (ISD); Zusy (notes that some developers may be waiting pending possible changes in Inclusionary rate); Azeem says we’re not going to lower the Inclusionary requirement; Toner; Placed on File 9-0

It is at times like this that I look back at all the ideas floated during the Envision Cambridge process and come to the conclusion that the Community Development Department has simply tossed it all into the wastebasket. Surely there is a “third way” somewhere between the current status and having Mass. Ave. and other corridors lined end-to-end with 12-story and higher buildings.


Order #2. That the City Manager is requested to work with the Cambridge Police Department to review current crisis prevention protocols, strengthen them by clearly defining the role and deployment of mental health professionals.   Councillor Wilson, Vice Mayor McGovern, Councillor Siddiqui
Order Adopted 9-0

Order #5. That the City Manager is requested to work with the Cambridge Police Department, the Law Department, and relevant stakeholders to develop and present to the City Council a proposed policy for the timely release of body-worn camera footage.   Councillor Azeem, Councillor Sobrinho-Wheeler, Councillor Nolan, Councillor Siddiqui
pulled by Zusy; comments by Zusy, Azeem, Nolan, McGovern; Order Adopted 9-0

These Orders grew out of a Public Safety Committee meeting last week in which the Cambridge Police Department provided the facts and almost all of Public Comment (except me) provided the fiction. In Cambridge, the tail continues to wag the dog.


Order #3. That the City Manager is requested to work with the Commission on Immigrant Rights & Citizenship, the City Solicitor, the Police Department, the Mayor’s Office, and other relevant stakeholders to evaluate and implement ICE Encounter Guidance.   Mayor Simmons, Vice Mayor McGovern
pulled by Simmons; comments by Simmons, McGovern, Yi-An Huang, Sobrinho-Wheeler, Nolan, Wilson; Order Adopted 9-0


Charter Right #1. That the City Manager is requested to work with the appropriate City staff to ensure that, effective immediately (and for each fiscal year in which the Office for Tourism continues to receive TDMD funding) that the City shall redirect its municipal funding to distribute those funds equally among the Central Square Business Improvement District (BID), the East Cambridge Business Association, the Harvard Square Business Association, and the Kendall Square Association. [Charter Right – Toner, Sept 8, 2025]
Comments by Toner (w/Comm #1); Comments by Simmons, Wilson; Referred to Econ. Development & University Relations Committee 9-0

Communications #1. Candice Beaulieu, re: CIVITAS- TDMD FAQ Sept 2025.
pulled by Councillor Toner; Referred to Econ. Development & University Relations Committee 9-0

There is a back story here that hopefully will get aired more fully. – RW

« Newer Posts — Older Posts »

Powered by WordPress